Nice

By ChubbyButt - 16/01/2013 10:48 - Canada - Brampton

Today, I was at the doctor's for a regular check-up. When my appointment was over and I was about to walk out, she yelled across the room in front of everyone, "Oh and if you could lose some weight, that'd be great." FML
I agree, your life sucks 36 118
You deserved it 7 036

Same thing different taste

Top comments

Comments

You could actually sue for that, OP Something about not maintaining a patient's privacy and abiding by work place ethics But would you?

Again, obesity is an indicator of an unhealthy lifestyle, not a medical condition protected by privacy laws. That would be like trying to sue her because she announced the color of your hair. Were I a gambling man I would bet that the doctor just tried to use social pressure on the OP after she ignored the previous suggestions as most overweight individuals tend to.

This isn't illegal, just very rude. The patients would've been able to see OP was overweight, so the doctor didn't give them any information that they didn't already know. It would be illegal if she'd said OP's exact weight or some other personal information that the other people weren't aware of.

I am sure they didn't mean it in a hurtful way. Probably still should have said it in private though.

Talk about a violation of federal privacy laws!! Find a new doc and sue them!

It isn't a violation of anything, you twit. This is exactly why your legal system is so ****** up.

Coming from someone who is in a paramedic program this is a violation of federal privacy laws called HIPPA. The doctor shared information with someone who is not the patient and not in the patient care team. Look it up!

The doctor made an offhand remark. There was no disclosure of information...

That is sooo illegal, at least here in the states! I don't know about Canada. I have to assume there's some kind of law against it. I'd sue her butt & I don't believe in lawsuits. That's just sooo wrong! What about patient confidentiality? Get a lawyer, ASAP!!!

She can't sue for being embarrassed. If it were confidential medical history about OP then there would be a case, but being offended by someone isn't punishable by, well, anything.

It's actually not illegal in the US...very rude, but not illegal. It isn't actual confidential information. Things that they are required to keep confidential are procedures, prescriptions, diagnosis, address, age, etc. If the doctor had stated the OPs actual weight, then that would be a breach of confidentiality. But again, it was extremely RUDE and therefore morally wrong.

RedPillSucks 31

So, "You have a fat ass" is not a diagnosis?

QWERTZ98 1

@VBMG152 It was unprofeessional, however I don't see any reason why would OP want to sue her. I mean if somebody told you that you're fat on the street, would you sue them? When you are fat, everybody sees that and knows that, even if they don't tell you that. What's up with you Americans and lawsuits anyway? OP might aswell start losing some weight, if she doesn't want to hear comments like that.

RedPillSucks 31

Honest query: What country has the most lawyers per capita? I'm thinking that that advertising, over the decades, have conditioned the public to think "Sue 'em" as a basic conflict resolution method. How else can we support large masses of lawyers? Now, if we gave everyone guns, we wouldn't need lawyers... *runs from angry mob*

lilbit91011 6

I would write a letter to the office manager explaining what happened and how it made you feel. You should at the very least get some kind of apology.

wait, people can't tell you you're fat if you're actually fat?

It sounds like this was said as sort of an afterthought. I'm not, by any stretch of the imagineation saying the Dr. should have done this in this venue/method, mind you. Handled properly? Not a Chance. Done with malice? Ah no...Just a bit of social awkwardness. The Dr probably also feels like a total ass for doing it, if that's any comfort.

If the doc said it, it's kinda obvious it's not like the people didn't notice before. Get running, that worked for me.