Paper back writer

By Kim - 10/04/2009 07:12 - United States

Today, I got back a paper after a peer review. I had worked really hard on it over the last week and was proud of the end result. When I got the paper back, the only positive comment on the paper was, "Well, I really like the blue staple you used to hold it together." FML
I agree, your life sucks 54 887
You deserved it 5 255

Same thing different taste

Top comments

may_cause_fail 0

Colored staples are awesome. However, as long as whoever it was left constructive criticism, then you really have nothing to complain about. It can be hard to see something that you spent a lot of time on be unpopular, there are worse things. Not really an FML.

When I peer edit papers, I only pay attention to the things that are wrong. The purpose is to find places to make improvements. It isn't the editor's job to point out things you did well; that takes more of his or her time.

Comments

IrishPride12 0

It's annoying when kids can't take people's honest advice. I've done peer edits before on one of my best friend's papers and she started crying because I edited almost everything in it. I wasn't being rude or cruel, I wsa being honest. The paper was bad. It had mistakes that I only made in the 4th grade. Seriously. Get over yourself. If it was a bad paper, you totally deserved it. Stop being overdramatic. The person who edited your paper even tried to soften the blow by giving you at least some form of a complement. Just edit everything that was wrong with it and don't complain about your deficiencies online to complete strangers anymore. YDI.

IrishPride12 0

YDI. If it was a bad paper, then edit it. Peer reviews are the best kind because people realize that they actually AREN'T perfect. If the person took the time to edit all of it, good for them for trying their best to make you get a good grade. Take the editor's advice and completely change it.

IrishPride12 0
almostfunny 0

#65: "soften the blow by giving you at least some form of a complement." *compliment* Maybe you shouldn't be editing papers in the first place.

Wouldn't you rather hear it from them now than get a bad grade from your teacher?

#61: I've actually seen teachers write comments like that on people's papers (I'm a writing tutor). It's rude, but if they can't understand what you are trying to say, then they can't tell you how to make it better. Ask your teacher to look over the paper, and maybe they'll give you some constructive feedback.

DNLoveless 0

Wow. The person that graded it must have ADD or something. He could have been so distracted by the awesome staple that he couldn't concentrate on your paper.

You're supposed to write positive comments when you peer edit?

The same thing happened to me except he "liked the font I used". *laughs*