By Full Stomach Empty Wallet - 06/08/2015 10:50 - United States - Danvers

Today, I discovered that the five-star meal that my friend treated me to last night was actually meant to be repayment of the $200 I loaned her last month. I needed that money for bills and she refuses to give me another cent. FML
I agree, your life sucks 28 018
You deserved it 2 626

Same thing different taste

Top comments

RedPillSucks 31

worse than that, even if it did cost $200, she would have only eaten $100th worth, so where is the rest of the money

Comments

YDI, your friend took you out to a five star restaurant and treated you to an expensive meal as payment for money that you loaned her. I'm sorry that she paid for an expensive meal for you and won't give you more money atop that...

All of your comments on FMLs that I've seen are ridiculous. This makes no sense?? I'm sure OP wouldn't have accepted the meal they didn't know it was repayment for the loan. OP probably thought it was just an act of kindness from a friend.

RedPillSucks 31

this logic is wrong. suppose by some stretch of the imagination, OPs friend did actually spend $200 on a meal. She ate half, so OP would still be owed $100. Now think about the money OP lent. Her friend could spend that money on anything, yet for repay it via a meal, she doesn't allow OP to have choice in how it's spent. OPs friends position is morally indefensible

You are a moron. If you give out money, you return money. 'nuff said. I have been burned by a friend who thought buying me a statue was a good repayment on a loan. Do you think the pawn shop would let me resell them the statue for 100% price they sold it to my friend? (she threw away the receipt)

I'm actually sorry I've experienced this myself so so sorry Op

theamazingd 17

You ought to take her to small claims court. That's not acceptable.

You should have clarified with her before you went to dinner. The fact that she can afford to treat you to a five star meal but not pay you back is reason enough for you to have asked for your money right then and there.

If someone owes you money, you expect money unless the person and you make other arrangements. OP obviously didn't know about this arrangement so it shouldn't be considered a repayment.

It's legally not considered a repayment either. If both of the involved parties agree to repay the debt through a meal, instead of actual money, then that'd be a different story. But as it is, if you owe someone e.g. 200 bucks, you HAVE to pay them back 200 bucks. You can seperately agree on something else, but the default is that you have to return what you borrowed from someone else, not just something you consider to be of equal value. Aside from that, this now basically comes down to word-against-word. If OP can get proof of the loan having been taken, better yet if the "friend" declares that they consider the loan repayed through the meal, then OP has the legal high-ground because there was never any agreement on substituting the 200$ through a meal. If OP can't get proof of the loan, though, then the "friend" is in the more favorable position.

IvyChennyChen 21

Both FYL and YDI 1) it's true she's being a bitch for not returning your 200$ 2) you shouldn't have expected her to pay for an expensive 5 star meal and expect her to still pay you back... Idk about how your friendship works but between my friends and me, we split the tab. That way, no one person is burdened with the bill. Maybe she wasnt clear but you should've made it clear to her before accepting that meal. So, sorry but FYL and YDI.

I take friends out for dinner all the time and vice versa. If I lend someone money, I expect money back in return unless another arrangement has been made. OP obviously didn't know about this arrangement, so this is on the friend.

leogachi 15

@32 How did you come to that conclusion? The friend told Op that she was going to treat her to a meal, it's not like Op just stuck her with the bill.

I have loaned many friends some money. Multiples times they pay me back AND treat me to dinner to show me that they are thankful. I have also split tabs and bought meals for friends on countless occasions. I am just saying that none of those are strange occurrences. If I give someone 200$ I expect that back in cash unless otherwise decided between the two of us.

Geckosrock99 33

If you think about it, that's a very expensive crap. Anyway, ditch the "Friend". I doubt it would fly if you pulled that with her. She doesn't sound like the type.

Well that didn't work out as planned...the amount the bill cost she couldn't pay you back?

RedPillSucks 31

never lend money that you aren't prepared to lose

Axel5238 29

OP, gotta agree with 32. This is FYL and YDI. Lending money like that you should set the terms for paying back before hand. Also, if there wasn't some sort of special occasion as of recent I'd question why someone was treating me to such an expensive meal. Some people have to be told that in certain situations that the favor has to be returned in the same manner and not in something equal of value.