Freaked out
By Anonymous - 24/08/2015 19:18 - United States - San Francisco
By Anonymous - 24/08/2015 19:18 - United States - San Francisco
By 0ptimu5 - 11/09/2009 04:39 - Australia
By Anonymous - 05/06/2012 19:34 - United States - Pocatello
By divingconfidence - 22/12/2012 11:21 - United States - Maple Grove
By Erick - 11/05/2024 18:00 - United States
By Anonymous - 23/11/2014 01:33 - United States - Chicago
By thatswhatsup66 - 20/03/2012 19:01 - United States - Greer
By creepyguy - 26/12/2009 12:06 - Australia
By DopeDickDover - 26/10/2015 15:50 - United States
By Anonymous - 17/02/2017 18:00 - United States - Dayton
By Idiot - 22/02/2017 04:00 - United States - Anchorage
Perhaps it wasn't so much your smile, as the fact that you failed to return to compliment and continue flirting, and just returned a grin. Could be interpreted as "Yes, I'm hot, and no, you're not". I'm always at a loss for words when someone compliments my looks, and I just end up smiling while struggling to think of a response. It can be unsettling, I'm sure.
Maybe it wasn't about the smile. Maybe you were supposed to tell her that she was hot too, instead of just saying "thanks".
Sheldon Cooper smile?
Someday you'll meet someone who thinks you have the best smile in the world :)
Your smile just outshined her personality :)
The Grin Nightmare
I guess I'm one of those weird people because I would've found your smile endearing. You'll find the one OP!
Keywords
You must have a killer smile, OP!
Sucks! Don't take it personally though, plenty more girls around! :)