And that's why she loves you. :CD

At least she didn't go psycho on you.

i made this account just because i had to comment this. this is not a ydi or a fml. this is really cute. i definitely agree with whoever suggested making this a cute tradition. give her the same card every year with whatever gift you think she'll like the most. that way it would be even more thoughtful.

Really, don't feel bad. That's so cute. :) And understandable. If you like a card, really like it, you'd pick it again and again. So it shows her that you care enough to read every card and pick one you like. And also shows that she cares enough to keep the one from previous years. Just smile, shrug, and try not to do it again. She's definitely happy that you remembered and that you got a card you like a lot. Random but wow, your store recycles cards for a while. We change them out here every so often.

bad memory much? at least he gave it the effort

Whoaa she could have reacted a lot worse. Consider yourself lucky, sir (: (Where's the FML?)

My parents have done this to me, 3 times, with the same card. XP

I can see my own boyfriend doing the exact same thing. He has a horrible memory. I got a better story for you that might help you feel better. One time in the middle of sex he thought he was dreaming. Apparently he dreams of giving me anal xD. He's adorable. Anyway, you're lucky. I see too many dumb bitches who completely lose it on small things like this. Good luck with your memory. Google "improving my memory", that should help.

I have done this numerous times. I like the same cards apparently. now my wife expects it. i think i have done it five times now.

that's cute. dumb cute.