By pianoblues - 17/10/2016 20:22 - Canada - Thunder Bay
Same thing different taste
By embarrassed - 18/11/2010 02:31
Is that a pass then?
By Anonymous - 12/09/2020 11:01 - Hong Kong - Central District
Feeling a light 4 on this one
By Anonymous - 02/08/2024 22:00 - Hong Kong - Kowloon
Pianissimo
By Anonymous - 20/06/2010 07:21 - United States
By auto boogie man - 19/11/2015 16:44 - United States - New York
By some band player - 10/03/2014 02:09 - United States - Highland Park
By pianonerd - 15/09/2009 06:16 - Canada
Inappropriate Billy Joel
By Anonymous - 18/04/2016 19:28 - United States - Carlisle
By American idol - 06/04/2011 06:19
By gassy - 29/12/2012 09:32 - United States - Kirkland
Top comments
Comments
I was in a jazz band in high school. They considered piano a percussion instrument and my role in the band was keeping the beat through chords.
Maybe she thought you had a good sense of rhythm
Umm piano is a percussion instrument though...
Remember a piano IS a percussion instrument
Actually playing piano well is normally a requirement for percussion. I didnt read it as an FML as it sounds like you played piano so well that they want you to do percussion. Which is a HUGE compliment. From a former percussionist:)
I would have said that to you if you were great, but I already had a piano player in mind and I wanted to find something else for you.
They're not saying you're bad, quite the opposite actually. As all musical instruments need some degree of musical ability to play well. If you were bad they would have shown you the door. Or it may have been a test to see if your knowledge of piano was vast enough to know that it was a percussion instrument, or to see how you would take it. In which case you would have failed, horribly.
Piano is a percussion instrument...
Keywords
You probably weren't bad. Honestly, she may have found someone a little bit better, but I'm not saying you did a bad job. I think that when auditions are held they have to find the absolute best. But I think it's really great that she offered you another part.
She might see some talent in you that you don't even know about. You never know where it can take you OP.