By Anonymous - 20/11/2015 19:27 - United States - Clearwater

Today, I found out my coworker was arrested for beating the crap out of his wife. I gave him a serious pep talk yesterday where I told him to stop taking her shit and start standing up for himself. FML
I agree, your life sucks 25 998
You deserved it 5 153

Same thing different taste

Top comments

Sorry OP, how could you have known that he would take your advice to such an extreme? Hopefully she's alright

Comments

What did she do to him to drive him that far? I'm surprised no one asked that and demonized him immediately

There's at least five comments that either question if the wife was abusive or present the possibility that she was. The closest comments to "demonizing" the husband are ones that say he took it too far even in the case that it was self defense and the comments that point out that it is a common suspicion deflection attic for abusers to claim to be the victim. Both of which are true statements. In some states the husband would have charges filed for being the least injured, in other states both the husband and wife would face charges. In the case of her being abusive and him snapping, if he kept hitting her after she was unable to injure him, it was no longer about self defense but about revenge. If he was abused to the extent that while he was defending himself he could no longer tell if she was a threat to him, his case will probably be built around the "battered wife/spouse" defense. Most of the comments seem geared towards pointing out that the OP isn't responsible for his coworker's choice either physically attack her(if she wasn't being physically violent) or for his decision to not stop once she was deterred enough he could escape. I will accept that there seems to be a focus on physical abuse as the culprit here- it is possible that the wife was emotionally and mentally abusive but never physically harmed the coworker. If that's the case and he physically retaliated for the no physical abuse, it will make his defense much harder because of the skewed perception society has of emotional abuse, particularly when men are the victims. Mostly because of the flawed idea that any man that is injured by emotional abuse isn't a "real" man. Basically I am saying that the comment section has been rather neutral on castigating either spouse without more information on their home life.

MonstreBelle 29

GhostFox, your comments have been very well said. I can honestly say that my thoughts, feelings, and comments would be exactly the same if the genders were reversed. My problem isn't that a man beat a woman. Rather, my problem is one person beat another. Gender is not important. Violence is violence and it's inexcusable, regardless of whatever arbitrary factors like gender, race, etc. exist. This is, of course, excluding self-defense. And nobody is denying that this situation could have come out of abuse and very well may have been self-defense. There is a line though. There is a point where the situation is no longer a credible threat to your safety and well-being. When someone continues after a threat has been subdued, they are no longer defending themselves. They are seeking revenge and punishing a person. Vigilante justice is not okay and defending it is a very slippery slope.

ezrajab 22

Don't beat urself up over that it wasn't you who punched her

It's not your fault he took it the wrong way.

It's not your fault that he took your advice this way. I know you must feel shitty about it, but you couldn't have known.

BeccaSedai 7

Some types of people will complain to everyone around them about how their partner is awful and critical and abusive towards them, when in actual fact it is the complainer who is the abusive partner. Someone who is willing to assault their partner is almost undoubtedly abusive in other ways, and has been for a long time. I doubt your "pep talk" had anything to do with this man's actual choice to do violence that day.

Now you know you can start your career as a motivational speaker.

Well you know you are an excellent motivational speaker. Maybe you should look into coaching? Just try not to suggest physically beating the other team. Leagues tend to frown on that.

You can stand up for yourself without beating the shit out of someone. Not your fault. Don't feel guilty and he can't blame it on you either.

FalconWhitaker 20

You weren't to know he'd hear the words "Stand up for yourself" and interpret that as "Vicious physical assault". There's a difference between assertiveness and aggression: encouraging the former does not make you responsible for the latter. This isn't your fault.

lovebug177 21

Maybe she was beating him so he stood up for himself -defended himself. Domestic abuse can go both ways

True. Doesn't sound like that's what happened though...