By imchacon22 - 26/10/2013 22:42 - United States - Fort Riley
imchacon22 tells us more.
Just to clear things up it is technically my house. My parents are rather well off and gave me a house and it's under my name. This was before we got married. Things he bought before we got married are technically his and things we have gotten since we have been married are ours. And for the person who said he defended our country so he should be allowed to do that, no honey just because he served our country doesn't make him entitled to make decisions like this without me. His mom has only met me once when she came to stay with us and in that short week she managed to insult me each and every single day and to act like she was running things. She isn't in need either it's just that his sister and brother don't want her living with them either because of the way she acts and demands things so I guess he's doing it to get her off their backs. But anyways maybe he'll change his mind or she will get a job and a place of her own.
Top comments
Comments
Majority if the time, mother-in-laws are the worst. Good luck.
This is not good. She will be in the middle of your relationship and ruin it if she is one of those "still attached by umbilical cord" kind of mom's.
Just to clear things up it is technically my house. My parents are rather well off and gave me a house and it's under my name. This was before we got married. Things he bought before we got married are technically his and things we have gotten since we have been married are ours. And for the person who said he defended our country so he should be allowed to do that, no honey just because he served our country doesn't make him entitled to make decisions like this without me. His mom has only met me once when she came to stay with us and in that short week she managed to insult me each and every single day and to act like she was running things. She isn't in need either it's just that his sister and brother don't want her living with them either because of the way she acts and demands things so I guess he's doing it to get her off their backs. But anyways maybe he'll change his mind or she will get a job and a place of her own.
Why are you waiting for him to change his mind? Tell him no - period. Remind him of the way she treated you on your one and only visit with her and tell him that you are not going to live like that on a full time basis. The fact that the house is in your name isn't even an issue here. What is an issue is that he thinks he can move people into the house without bothering to make sure that you are ok with it. Then again if he does not have the heart to say no he just might be waiting for you to step up and do it for him. "Sorry, my wife won't let me." is a much easier thing to tell your mother than the truth. Either way it will be a definite fml and f your marriage if you let someone who does not respect you move in.
It sound like both of you have some control issues. If neither of you owned the house and you were renting the house, it STILL would not be okay for him to invite his mother to move in with you. It is a decision of such magnitude that neither of you should even CONSIDER making it without talking to the other one. And your saying "It's MY house, so I get to decide," is just a tactic for asserting your own control over the situation. Maybe you should consider couples counseling.
It seems your husband is used to living with his family and assumes you'd feel the same. I hope you tell him how you feel and that he's willing to discuss things. If not, this might be a red light in your marriage.
If it was my husband, it would be mother in law out or both her and the husband out. His decision. And I understand she'd want to live nearby, but no closer than 5 minutes by bicycle. That's walking distance, but not making it too easy. Last: Our home, our rules. If you behave like a nice guest, you'll be treated like one, if you behave like a bossy mother in law, you'll be treated not as nice.
Whether or not the house is in your name (or his, or both), he should've run it by you. You guys are supposed to be partners and big decisions like that should be unanimous -or at the very least discussed.
I have to agree with 68 & 105! You can't live like that, it will damage if not ruin your marriage. If her undermining and insults don't drive you away, the irritation that he put you in this position will drive a wedge between you. You guys are a team, he cant just up and move his mother in, at the same time, you can't play the its my house card (unless its the excuse he gives his mother as to why she can't move in) I get the yours, mine, ours thing but at some point, it has to all be ours to be a real team. For the marriage, say NO!! Good luck OP!
and I'm sorry to tell you but when you get married your supposed to be as one flesh as one. That means it's as much his house as it is yours
Not sure where you guys are from, but according to laws around here it doesn't matter if it's "technically" yours. The law says married couples share 50% of *everything*. Assets, debt, etc.
yeah, hang on to that pipe dream.
It does suck that he didn't ask you first but what does the fact that it's your house have to do with anything? You're married now, just because you had the house before you were married doesn't mean you get to call all of the shots
doesn't mean he gets to call all the shots either. you just debunked your own argument.
Absolutely 100% right. She needs to wake up to reality
At this point, it doesn't matter whether it's strictly under your name. You're married, which means it's his house too. He's not a *guest* there, he's your husband. But it doesn't mean he should get to call shots like that without your input. I would talk to him about it and tell him my thoughts, if I were you, because that's not a fair call on his part. FYL.
Actually you are incorrect there about it being "their" house. Just because you are married does not mean that something like a house is both of yours. If his name is on the title and the tax papers, then he might have a claim to it, but if not, it would be solely hers. The only way around that is IF they are in a community property state where everything is half and half and there is no prenup stating that the house will always be hers.
Keywords
Why are you waiting for him to change his mind? Tell him no - period. Remind him of the way she treated you on your one and only visit with her and tell him that you are not going to live like that on a full time basis. The fact that the house is in your name isn't even an issue here. What is an issue is that he thinks he can move people into the house without bothering to make sure that you are ok with it. Then again if he does not have the heart to say no he just might be waiting for you to step up and do it for him. "Sorry, my wife won't let me." is a much easier thing to tell your mother than the truth. Either way it will be a definite fml and f your marriage if you let someone who does not respect you move in.
That's pretty ****** up that your husband wouldn't talk to you first about someone moving in, even if it's family. Hopefully she's not a monster-in-law, right?