Were you making a grille for them?

give them a toothy grin

but really that sucks

you guys take teeth for store credit at ur store too?

What was their response?

I wanna hear the story behind this

Well I know jewelry stores can charge an "arm and a leg," but I've never heard them charging a canine and a molar.

Did they try to cut their teeth on wedding rings?

When my grandpa got his third teeth he put all of his teeth that had gold fillings in a small jar for "bad times" (he was a WWII survivor, so in that context it isn't half as insane as it sounds). When he died, my mum took the teeth to a jewelry store that bought them to extract the gold and use it for making jewelry. So, maybe your fancy wedding ring contains a bit of my grandpa's molars. You're welcome. I think something similar was probably going on in OPs store.

Okay we gotta know OP, what the shit?