Why would you try to compliment her by comparing her to a horse?

YDI because you obviously sub-consciously want to have sex with a horse. Buy her a "My Little Pony", a couple of sugar cubes, and nuzzle up to her.

Try calling her a cow next time, see if that works out for you.

YDI for thinking that "you've got horse legs" would pass for a compliment. (Especially if the reason she was depressed was because of self-confidence or body issues)

i think you didn't think about how should would react to that, did you? lmao, you really didn't ******* think that one through. (saying a girls legs are as strong as a horse isn't exactly something a girl would like to hear) YDI, think before you say things.

WOW you SOOOO deserved that :P

...never, *ever* tell women they're remotely like *any* animal, even the cutest ones on the planet. Just skip to the adjectives you're associating and leave out the nouns >.> Your heart was in the right place, buuuut... YDI for nothing thinking:-p

...I don't understand her reaction at all, and I'm a girl. Honestly, that seems like a pretty good compliment to me. I mean, it should have been obvious to her that you meant it as a compliment; therefore, she should have been able to deduce that you meant her legs were horselike with respect to their musculature rather than with respect to, for example, hair. If I had put a lot of effort into developing strong legs, I'd be overjoyed to have someone comment on them. I could understand it if she just said "Hey!" or something, but accepted the compliment after you explained what you meant. But to cry over it for an hour and a half? That's just a ridiculous overreaction. Who cares if you compared her to an animal? You meant it in a positive way, and that should be what counts.

Atleast you didnt call her a donkey or a cow.

I already saw this today on textsfromlastnight.com's page on facebook.