Focus group

By Jay - 10/04/2009 14:41 - Germany

Today, my mate came over wanting me to listen to a new music CD he got. It was by some unknown band, and at the end he asked me what I thought, and I said it was ok but the lead singer couldn't sing even if his life depended on it. Turns out my mate's the lead singer, and it was his own band. FML
I agree, your life sucks 28 331
You deserved it 43 160

Same thing different taste

Top comments

shiie 0

Well he asked, so he got what he wanted.

Agree with #1....he didn't tell you whose band it was before he got your opinion on the subject because he wanted an honest opinion out of you. You gave him one- he should've told you it was his band before asking an opinion if he was just fishing for a compliment.

Comments

So? He asked your opinion, and you gave your honest opinion, he shouldn't get mad. My band did the same thing to another friend of ours and he said about the same thing. You know what we did? We pushed the singer back to lead guitar, and got another guy who has more of a melodic voice. It was one of the best decisions we ever made. The old singer wasn't even mad either.

It was your honest opinion, and it's exactly he asked for. not an FML, and certainly not your fault.

FkThisLife 6

You kept it real that's a good thing

We need more people like OP on American Idol to tell people they can't sing.

tiredofwaiting 25

I don't think that is all that bad. It is constructive criticism. He asked for an opinion you have him one. People should not ask for one if they cannot handle the truth. Constructive criticism is to help the other person.

OP at least you had the balls to be honest. It sucks for your friend but with practice and coaching he can get better. Imagine how your friend feels. "Today, my best mate listened to my band and said I can't sing. FML"