By Anonymous - 12/10/2014 20:46 - United States - Gainesville

Today, I received an email from an angry parent, demanding that I give his daughter an A on a project which I had given her a 0 on. The project was to pick an article related to science and to write an essay on it. Hers was a hoax article relating to Ebola patients rising from the dead. FML
I agree, your life sucks 39 600
You deserved it 5 708

Same thing different taste

Top comments

Indianboy9321 25

It's one thing to politely ask you to allow his daughter to redo the assigned work with a proper article, and it's another thing to "demand" a near-perfect score for nowhere near acceptable work...

SharnaaaBanana 22

It really amazes me how ignorant some people can be.

Comments

#56 is right. Ill find the article if you guys want

As an educator myself, I almost have to side with the student. while it was a hoax article, the student A. did the work and B. stayed within the realm of science. Personally, I would have given her a C and told her she could bring it up to a b if she wrote another article. now, depending where you're at in the quarter, you're making it difficult for this student to pass.

She didn't do the work at all. She may have wrote a wonderful agruement on the validity of a hoax article but never once did I see it metion her turning in an essay on a scientific article. Its the same as me writing a movie review about a book and hoping the teacher will pass me. Just like a book isn't the same as a movie a hoax article isn't the same as a scientific article.

Plus the teacher doesn't have to guarantee the students pass. Students must work and complete assignments following the criteria given in order to earn the right to pass. Your reasoning is what is responsible for letting students with a 5th grade education graduate from highschool.

This is actually real. But they weren't exactly rising from the dead.

You never said the article OR the essay had to be scientifically correct... :O

So what do you teach, English or physics? In both cases I find you're wrong because her work should be rated and not the topic. Science, science fiction it's all possible. Look a little at history and things that have happened and changed in the last two hundred years

Look at the second word in Science fiction for me. It clearly states it is not true. I can tell you have a second grader's understanding of true science. Let me educate you, in order to become a Scientific theory a hypothesis must be tested hundreds of times by various people and have the same outcome. Until then its just guess work. Take it from a chemistry major ebola zombies doesn't even constitute a hypothesis let alone a theory so no article about it is science in any form.

mansen 15

One doesn't have to teach to actually understand what science actually is. Or what the difference between science and science fiction is. One can actually pay attention in their basic science classes. Or be in higher education for a section of science too. Where it is drilled into us what a scientific hypothesis is, a scientific theory is, how real research is set up, what to look at and for in research articles. Also that yes, science does change with time, with technology that allows better use, understanding, manipulations, closer look at many many things. But, before anything becomes rigorously set as yes this is it, it has to be tested (and they test to try to disprove it not prove it) hundreds of times by many different people, to get the same consistent results. Science fiction is whatever your mind can make up and put onto paper, does not need any testing. See the difference??

Teaching is rough and parents are asshats. In today's world their kids are always right. When this changed, I don't know.

May I add that all science starts out as speculative too. You need to read up yourself, NDE for example, CDC in the US has emergency response guidelines for a possible zombie apocalypse. (Center for disease control) Don't be so narrow minded in future

Well, to be fair, the CDC started the zombie thing as a joke. They say in their website it was tongue-in-cheek. Then they saw they could use that theme to reach all kinds of people to prepare them for hazards. It's right there on their website, "you need to read up yourself".

But it doesn't become accepted as science until it is proven and so your argument is invalid.

mansen 15

please please please tell me that you do realize that the zombie preparedness part on the CDC is all tongue in cheek and was in part due to the huge popularity of zombies in pop culture. If you do not realize that, it is not our narrow mindedness we have to worry about, it is just what you believe to be real science.

They still do the assignment you should have atleast given them some points you asshole