By Anonymous - 12/10/2014 20:46 - United States - Gainesville

Today, I received an email from an angry parent, demanding that I give his daughter an A on a project which I had given her a 0 on. The project was to pick an article related to science and to write an essay on it. Hers was a hoax article relating to Ebola patients rising from the dead. FML
I agree, your life sucks 39 600
You deserved it 5 708

Same thing different taste

Top comments

Indianboy9321 25

It's one thing to politely ask you to allow his daughter to redo the assigned work with a proper article, and it's another thing to "demand" a near-perfect score for nowhere near acceptable work...

SharnaaaBanana 22

It really amazes me how ignorant some people can be.

Comments

School problems won't be problems as soon as Ebola gets here

I imagine the ability to recognize actual science was a big part of the assignment. Something a lot of people apparently have difficulty doing. *smh*

Did she agree with the article's position? If so, then she deserved the 0. On the other hand, if she tried to argue it's falsehood, then she deserved SOME kind of credit.

so what your saying is: as long as you do EXACTLY what i say, you'll do well. ANY creative deviance will result in failure. Welcome to the American teaching system. crush out all differences, everyone must fit into this straight line. Was the essay well written? That's what should matter. not the fact that she got creative. if it was full of "likes" and "umm's" okay fine, but if you failed her simply on the fact of the article she chose the it's YDI. Start teaching individuality, not forcing people into a single mold.

The student could have chosen any of the thousands of actual science related articles but they purposely chose a known hoax she was being a smartass.

mansen 15

If the assignment was to write a piece of fiction or assess a piece of fiction, go for it. Be creative. But to foster critical thinking skills, to help a person develop skills in assessing if something is valid, how to look to see if it is true, and not to fall prey to the many many idiotic conspiracy theory circles that rely on those very lack of skills, then yes, these things have to be taught. It is not crushing out individuality, it is helping create people who are less likely to be duped by every dumb thing they see, read and hear. Being able to properly assess a science article in the news is one of those things that being wildly creative was not asked for for the assignment. If she took that article and came up with verified, sound research to show why it was a hoax, was not valid, and not possible, then fine, it would have been a good essay. But if she just took it and wrote about how people were talking about zombies from ebola victims, then no. She failed.

Did you say when giving your assignment that it had to be a real article?

Sure its related to science.... science fiction that is.

You didn't have to give a 0. I think partial credit would have been fine since she still did some work.

Is the family religious? It's possible they might actually believe in divine healing which may not be science related, but could explain where they're coming from.

Yeah but it's fun to pretend. Have you read the zombie survival guide? It's actually a very good disaster survival guide.