Maybe you were in a weird or awkward position that made it difficult to fully feel the entirety of your manhood.

Tell her "It's not the meat it's the motion" OP. it's not true and she won't believe it but maybe you can salvage a little teeny weeny bit of self esteem!

The world is life saving medicine. Like penis enlargement pills.

You should put some super-stiff hair gel on your pubes -- that'll fool her for the next date or two.

It's not merely the size of the boat, but rather, the motion of the ocean. Unless there is a raging typhoon. Ask your gf if she is a massive, ship crushing hurricane. If that answer is yes, tell her to sew it up and take her charlatan tricks elsewhere.

You might want to go see a doctor if you feel insecure. But yet again, he might direct you to Weenie Hut General.

That is ****** up for her and you.

Why was she trying to touch your penis if it was your first time making out with her?! Shouldn't she be nervous or something?

Sounds like she doesn't even know what "hard" is then.

Interesting that it's the guys who say it's how you use it...