Overreaction

By rejected - 13/04/2012 05:09 - United States - Charlotte

Today, my girlfriend saw the name "Melissa" on my phone's contact list. After refusing to tell her who it was, she accused me of being a cheater, broke up with me and stormed out of my house. Melissa is the name of a woman from Craigslist who was going to sell me an antique engagement ring. FML
I agree, your life sucks 45 778
You deserved it 9 410

Same thing different taste

Top comments

You could have told her that it was because of a present to her... Then no loose ends to misunderstand on :) Fyl though, she sounds kind of insecure.. If she really love you, maybe she will want you back

Comments

that sucks OP! But it sounds like she doesn't deserve it. She should have checked with you before freaking out, a good relationship relays on trust. Keep your head high OP.

She's going to feel so bad when she finds out.. Guess you could use that to your advantage? ;)

That shows no trust; if she's asking about a girls name just because she's on your phone, then she mustn't trust you a whole lot, and for marriage to work there needs to be trust. But you could explain the whole situation to her and then she might feel stupid for not trusting you and she'll learn from that. :)

U should of just told her melissa was Jackass

josiemorehouse 12

Sorry but I can understand OP's girl's reaction. I am one of those people who can become jealous or suspicious. She asked about a female contact in his phone, and OP refused to be honest with her. I would've had the same reaction. OP should've been honest to an extent, say that he's working on a surprise for his GF, that the female contact is the saleswoman, and that's all the info she's gonna get!! All of you spout about trust, but OP was obviously lying or covering something up. I'm sorry, but you totally deserved it. Next time, give your GF at least a part of the truth. You want her to trust you? Don't lie to her.

Because "part" of the truth is so easily doable OP: She.... Ummmm.... Sells engagement rings on craiglist, and I thought that was nice.... No no no, I didn't buy one from her Yeah. Totally legit. Besides, he didn't lie, he just didn't tell her who she was. If you're truly like that, you're overpossessive, paranoid, and you believe the guys you date are so dumb they can't even prepare a good excuse beforehand even though they're two-timing and don't want to be caught.

josiemorehouse 12

If OP would've given her part of the truth, he could've save himself some trouble. I'm happily married, have a perfectly happy marriage because my husband and I don't hide things from each other. If I saw a strange woman's number in his phone, I'd ask first. If he refused to tell me anything, I would behave the same way, I'd feel betrayed and wouldn't feel comfortable trusting him. OP is starting off his engagement by lying. Granted it may be ultimately for a good cause, there is never an OK reason to lie or hide things from your partner.

theonlysweetpea 10

#200 How did OP lie?! He refused to tell. If he would have said anything other than "The woman's whose ring I'm buying for you!", he would have been lying! That's bull. Also bull is believe that "You're going out in that!?" is that same as "I don't think you should wear that.". Telling the truth is not the same as being an asshole about it. People confuse the two on purpose

sorry OP. You should have put her under a guys name in your phone. Wait... why is she going through your phone anyway?!?! That's a bigger problem.

I never get cheated on becuse I AM BATWOMANN!!!

I'm gonna go out on a limb here and say it's that second N that keeps'm faithful to ya.

Maybe she went to go get you a dr paper!

YDI. What did you think she was going to do Now you're screwed unless you were smart enough to tell one of her friends in advance just in case something like this happened. I really feel sorry for you.

You never tell your girlfriend's friends anything thats a suprise. They always tell them.

Wow that is a tough one, my friend. Fyl