Overreaction

By rejected - 13/04/2012 05:09 - United States - Charlotte

Today, my girlfriend saw the name "Melissa" on my phone's contact list. After refusing to tell her who it was, she accused me of being a cheater, broke up with me and stormed out of my house. Melissa is the name of a woman from Craigslist who was going to sell me an antique engagement ring. FML
I agree, your life sucks 45 778
You deserved it 9 410

Same thing different taste

Top comments

You could have told her that it was because of a present to her... Then no loose ends to misunderstand on :) Fyl though, she sounds kind of insecure.. If she really love you, maybe she will want you back

Comments

yesyesnonono 10

Buy the ring, tell her you got it from Melissa, and propose right after.

ElhonnaDS 10

Sometimes it's hard to fully explain the story in the space you get for the FML. By "refusing to tell her" I'm sure he didn't mean that he just said "I'm not telling you a darn thing so deal with it." He probably said "It's a surprise, so I can't tell you," or, "I can't tell you right now, but trust me you'll be happy I didn't," or something that. Give people some credit for basic communication skills. And I don't think it would have been better to lie- if the lie didn't hold up it looks worse than the truth. I do think you dodged a bullet, though. If she doesn't trust you, then there is something missing in that relationship and it's better for both of you.

Idiot. White lies never hurt anyone. No matter what veggie tales says.

HITide76808 0

U shouldve just told her from the get-go. By refusing makes it look like your hiding something. Other than that communication, trust and honesty is the key to a healthy relationship

Who saves the name of a person you don't know personally to their contacts?...I'm not buying it either...

I do, especially if I need to organize to pick something up after buying it.

A contact in a phone it's just a person you need to phone at some point, wheter if you know personally that person or not. It's not that difficult to understand. Still, I wouldn't save her contact with just "Melissa" (specially because I have really a bad memory with names and I would end up looking through all contacts to see if any of them would ring a bell)

she did u a FAVOR !! runnnn you deff dont need her in ur life if shes crazy about a girls NAME in ur phone smh

What did you think was gonna happen? What if she had a guy contact that she wouldn't tell you about? YDI

hope_of_reptar 2

I'm very sorry for your horrific lost.

Why didn't you just say " I am looking to buy a gift for someone from Craigslist." ydi for refusing to say who it was and feeding the paranoia.

You deserved it... For dating a psycho control freak.