By tinytiny1124 - 14/04/2014 16:57 - United States - Columbus
Top comments
Comments
Is having mentally traumatised 3 year old for the next year worth a cuddle?
year? Only if she's lucky!
I was being optimistic. Besides, after a year he becomes a mentally traumatised 4 year old. :P
That's terrible. Why would you encourage or create a very young child's fears, especially in something imaginary, for your own benefit? If this develops into a serious/long-lasting fear you'll be sorry, and so you should be.
I wouldn't go that far. When I was really young, my cousin told me and her younger sister that they had a monster living in her room to keep us out. And then later on, it was about cannibals living in the vineyard nearby. Kids are tougher than that for the most part.
Kids also know their cousins and siblings are full of crap, though. They (are supposed to) trust their parents more than that.
Maybe the scary stories you were told didn't affect you, but OP has no way of knowing what their child's long-term temperament or mental health will be like at such a young age. They might grow up fine, but inciting fears could lead to anxiety or phobias. It could easily give them nightmares and make them clingy/overly reliant on the parent for a while if nothing else. Kids tell other kids scary stories, but they should be able to go home and have their parents tell them it was a silly story someone made up to scare them.
We believed her for years and never told our parents... I'm not saying what the OP did was right, but saying this will traumatize the child for years is a little too much. I don't know why everybody always assumes everything will traumatize children... That's why kids in general are getting softer and softer each year...
I didn't say it WOULD 'traumatize them for life' - I said it could give them nightmares, make them clingy, and POTENTIALLY AFFECT their long-term mental health, which again it could. Having a mental health problem is not entirely attributable to incidents like this, but they can contribute to phobias and anxiety. Children (or adults) with these conditions are not 'soft', and that attitude to mental health conditions contributes to their stigma.
Get a pet. Or a boyfriend. Or a pillow-hugger thing - that "boyfriend pillow"
The word you're looking for is body-pillow. There's quite a variety with anime characters of your pick ;D or Gaben Newell if that's your thing.
#14, all I can think if when I read your comment is a huge ape trying to get a dog to be it's friend & the dog is terrified.
Cuddles > lifelong fear of monsters
Bad idea. Now he's never going to his room.
If you have to tell your kid that just to lay with you, there's probably a reason why he won't lay with you
I hope your ready do deal with how hard it will be to put him to bed. How can he sleep when he thinks there are monsters around? You... Kinda deserved it.
He's probably never going to go back to his room.
Keywords
Well.. that's kind of desperate. Scaring a kid for yourself to cuddle o.o
Get a dog.