By me - 01/05/2011 16:31 - United States

Today, the tree that my neighbors have neglected to cut down fell on my car. They claim that by law, they aren't responsible and don't have to pay for it. FML
I agree, your life sucks 38 395
You deserved it 3 335

Same thing different taste

Top comments

TaylorTotsYumm 10

Get a crane to place the tree on top of their car.

plant a tree wait 30 years, then crush their house with it

Comments

If you were so worried abot this tree that you were asking them to cut it down repeatedly. Then why did you park in such a way that your car could be crushed.

Maybe he doesn't have a very big driveway and it's the only place he can park his car? :/ What is OP supposed to do... Park on the road?

redheadcaligurl 0

they are right it is not their problem your insurance will cover it... if not your car insurance then your home owners.

lillya555 0

I'm currently in law school and in my torts class we recently learned about the duties of owners/occupiers to people off their land. Assuming that the tree was on their land they are likely liable to you. In the majority of states owners' of land have no duty to people off their land but the one exception is in the case of trees falling onto adjoining land and physically damaging people or property. It sounds to me like your car being crushed would fall under this one exception in tort law so if I were you I would consult and attorney about this. I'm not sure of your jurisdiction so I can't be one hundred percent certain that your courts observe this exception, but it is the majority approach in the United States. I hope this is helpful to you.

fightin4fun 0

well actually, "by law", they do have to pay for it seeing as how it fell from there property onto your car. contact a judge.

Wow your fury hood is beautiful!!!! haha

good that no one is creeping today, but damn you eyes are beautiful ;) jk

Talk to a lawyer. They might be wrong.

magicman13 9

They are, and they certainly do. Hope they have a good lawyer.